Qualiopi8 min read

Qualiopi indicators that can lead to a minor non-conformity: the 15 graded indicators and the traps

Editorial lead: The Kit Certif team

The Qualiopi literature talks a lot about the “super indicators” — those where any gap is classed as a major non-conformity. Far less is said about the graded indicators, the only ones where a gap can “only” trigger a minor non-conformity. And the list is often wrong: many sites show eleven indicators that are “minor” by nature, which the reading guide does not say. Here is the actual rule, the exact list of the 15 indicators concerned, and the traps that turn a benign gap into a real problem. Important: this list applies to the 32-indicator framework in force until 31 October 2026 and its V8 reading guide; the weighting for the new framework has not been published yet.

An on-site check, checklist in hand
An on-site check, checklist in hand. Photo: USDAgov, CC BY 2.0

Reminder: what a minor non-conformity really means

The reading guide of the Référentiel National Qualité (RNQ, the national quality framework) sets a weighting of non-conformities: some indicators can only give rise to major non-conformities, while others are graded. On the graded ones, a minor non-conformity is recorded when the requirement is partly met, and a major one may be issued when it is not met at all. The consequences are very different:

  • a major non-conformity blocks the issue or maintenance of certification until it is cleared;
  • a minor non-conformity blocks nothing immediately: at the initial audit you submit a corrective action plan within 6 months, and the actual fix is checked at the surveillance audit at the latest.

The list of the 17 indicators that can only lead to a major finding — and the method to lock them down — is covered in our article on the Qualiopi “super indicators”. This one deals with its exact mirror: the 15 graded indicators.

“Minor possible” does not mean “optional”. The auditor assesses every indicator applicable to your activity, and a minor gap is recorded in the report like any other. What changes is the treatment: a longer deadline, no certificate blockage — but a quality debt that follows you to the next audit. And on these same indicators, a requirement ignored altogether is still a major finding.

The list of the 15 indicators that can lead to a minor non-conformity

Under the “Weighting of non-conformities” section of the reading guide (V8), reflected in our indicator guides:

Indicator Subject Who is concerned
Indicator 1 Public information about services Everyone
Indicator 2 Publication of results indicators Everyone
Indicator 3 Achievement and employment-outcome rates CFAs and relevant certifying courses
Indicator 8 Entry positioning and assessment of prior learning Everyone
Indicator 9 Information on delivery conditions Everyone
Indicator 12 Learner engagement, dropout prevention Everyone
Indicator 13 Coordination of work-linked learning Work-linked training, CFAs
Indicator 17 Human and technical resources Everyone
Indicator 18 Coordination of internal and external trainers Everyone
Indicator 19 Learning resources made available to learners Everyone
Indicator 23 Legal and regulatory monitoring Everyone
Indicator 24 Occupational and skills monitoring Everyone
Indicator 25 Pedagogical and technological monitoring Everyone
Indicator 28 Work-based training and work-linked schemes Work-linked training
Indicator 30 Collecting stakeholder feedback Everyone

Two useful readings of this table:

  • The apprenticeship indicators are not “minor”. Indicators 14, 15 and 29, often presented as such, can only lead to a major non-conformity: a CFA that treats them lightly takes a real risk.
  • The three monitoring indicators follow the same rule: indicators 23, 24 and 25 are all graded. Incomplete legal monitoring can stay minor; occupational monitoring that is entirely missing can be major.

A calendar nuance: decree n° 2026-728 of 1 August 2026, which takes the framework to 33 indicators on 1 November 2026, amends eleven existing indicators (1, 2, 3, 7, 12, 14, 15, 19, 20, 27 and 32) — including 12, 14 and 15 on preventing violence, harassment and discrimination — and creates an indicator 33 reserved for CFAs. The decree says nothing about the weighting of non-conformities: that belongs to the reading guide for the new framework, which had not yet been published as of 30 September 2026 (to our knowledge). The table above is therefore the V8 guide’s, applicable until 31 October 2026; for an audit from 1 November 2026, have your certification body confirm which weighting grid it will apply.

Why minor findings cluster on certain indicators

Several of these indicators share one trait: they rest on evidence of habit, not evidence of design. A training programme is written once; up-to-date results indicators, regular monitoring or attendance follow-up are produced continuously. That is exactly what slips first when activity speeds up.

The typical findings in audits:

  • Indicator 2: rates published with no date or calculation basis, or frozen for two years — our guide to calculating a clean satisfaction rate shows how to produce defensible figures without disproportionate effort;
  • Indicators 23, 24 and 25: newsletter subscriptions with no trace of exploitation — a monitoring table kept up to date fixes the problem in an hour a month;
  • Indicator 12: informal dropout follow-up, with no traced reminders;
  • Indicators 18 and 19: genuine coordination that is never formalised (no minutes, no list of resources provided).

The substance is almost always there; it is the trace that is missing. A study by Milena Alič and Borut Rusjan published in 2010 in the International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, “Contribution of the ISO 9001 internal audit to business performance”, shows that regular internal audits — precisely the tool that catches these small documentary drifts — contribute measurably to business performance, beyond mere compliance (see the study). In other words: handling these indicators continuously is also better management.

A stack of coloured binders and notebooks
A stack of coloured binders and notebooks. Photo: Muffet, CC BY 2.0

The three traps of the minor non-conformity

  1. Letting it live. An accepted corrective action plan is not a closed non-conformity. A minor finding still present at the next audit can be requalified as major — and you will have demonstrated to the auditor that your continuous improvement loop does not work, which this time touches an indicator that can only lead to a major finding.
  2. Confusing “graded” with “minor”. On these 15 indicators, only partial compliance stays minor: a website with no information at all on your services (indicator 1) or no feedback collection whatsoever (indicator 30) can earn a major finding.
  3. The rushed response. A minor finding is answered like a major one: cause analysed, dated action, supporting evidence. The method is detailed in our guide to the Qualiopi corrective action plan.

Securing them without giving up your evenings

The good news: several graded indicators applicable to a standard provider are secured with three short routines — publishing dated, sourced rates once a year (indicator 2), keeping a monitoring table one hour a month (23, 24 and 25), tracing learner-engagement follow-up at every session (12) — plus two one-off formalisations for trainer coordination (18) and the list of learning resources provided (19). Fold them into your six-monthly Qualiopi self-assessment and the matter is closed.

Take action

The Complete Kit Certif (€297, 14-day guarantee) covers all 32 indicators of the current framework — the 17 “always major” as well as the 15 graded ones — with ready-to-customise procedures, templates and evidence models; updated on 30 September 2026, it also includes a sheet for indicator 33 and the requirements applicable from 1 November 2026. Just starting out? The ebook “Create your training organisation in 30 days” (€49) lays the groundwork, and the full pack (€299) bundles both resources.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

+Which Qualiopi indicators can lead to a minor non-conformity?

For the framework in force until 31 October 2026, under the "weighting of non-conformities" in the reading guide of the Référentiel National Qualité (the French national quality framework, V8 of 23 November 2023), 15 of the 32 indicators are graded and can lead to a minor or a major non-conformity: indicators 1, 2, 3, 8, 9, 12, 13, 17, 18, 19, 23, 24, 25, 28 and 30. The other 17 (4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 20, 21, 22, 26, 27, 29, 31 and 32) can only lead to a major non-conformity. No indicator is "minor" by default. The weighting for the new 33-indicator framework, in force from 1 November 2026, had not been published as of 30 September 2026 (to our knowledge).

+What separates a minor from a major finding on a graded indicator?

The reading guide records a minor non-conformity when the requirement is partly met, and allows a major one when it is not met at all. Incomplete information on indicator 1 is therefore a minor finding; no information at all on your services can be a major one.

+Can a minor non-conformity make you fail a Qualiopi audit?

It does not block certification: at the initial audit you submit a corrective action plan within 6 months, and the fix is checked at the surveillance audit at the latest. However, a minor finding that is never corrected can be requalified as major at the next visit, and an accumulation of minor findings weighs on the auditor's overall assessment.

Read next